| Votes | Theory |
| 68 | James Hurley will open a vortex and is going to sleep with The Drunk |
| 60 | Denise Bryson is working with Charlie and is going to sleep with Bushnell Mullins |
| 47 | Wally Brando has a doppelganger and is going to sleep with Lucy Moran |
| 35 | Detective D. Fusco will find The White Lodge and is going to sleep with The Log Lady |
| 32 | Gordon Cole is the anonymous billionaire in New York and is going to sleep with Shelly Johnson |
| 28 | Bushnell Mullins is working with The Woodsmen and is going to sleep with Janey-E Jones |
| 23 | Dr. Lawrence Jacoby came from a Frog Moth and is working on Blue Rose |
| 15 | Dale Cooper is addicted to Sparkle and will kill Big Ed Hurley |
| 14 | Sonny-Jim Jones is working with Hank and is going to sleep with Sarah Palmer |
| 9 | Dale Cooper will find The White Lodge and will kill Donna Hayward |
| 8 | Andy Brennan is working with Mike Nelson and will be killed by Gordon Cole |
| 6 | Audrey Horne is in a coma and is the Dreamer |
| 3 | Janey-E Jones is working with Shelly Johnson and is going to sleep with Audrey Horne |
